Analysis Opinion

A Contested Forum: The 21st G20 Summit Heads to Miami

After a contentious 2025 summit in South Africa, which saw political outbursts and notable absences, the Miami summit will test the G20’s capacity to deliver as a meaningful multilateral forum.

From 14 to 15 December, world leaders will converge on Miami, Florida for the 2026 Group of 20 (G20) Summit under the presidency of the United States. This will be the first G20 hosted in the U.S. since 2009.

After a contentious 2025 summit in Johannesburg, South Africa, which saw political outbursts from U.S. President Donald Trump in the lead-up and the absences of leaders from Argentina, China, Indonesia, Mexico, Russia, Saudi Arabia, and the U.S., expectations for sustained, meaningful G20 cooperation remain low.

The Trump administration declares that the 2026 G20 is about “practical solutions, real outcomes, and American leadership that delivers prosperity, security, and strength at home and around the globe.” Its three priorities include addressing regulatory burdens, securing affordable energy supply chains, and bolstering innovations in artificial intelligence (AI) and emerging technologies.1 To progress on these themes, the G20 has organized four working groups focused on finance, innovation, energy, and trade.

Beginning with the finance ministerial in Asheville, North Carolina, which took place at the end of August, the U.S. has convened five ministerial meetings ahead of the Leaders’ Summit, along with several sherpa and preparatory meetings. In an attempt to showcase ‘American leadership’ in the G20 priority areas, the Trump administration has geographically distributed meetings across several locations to reflect private sector and industry hubs.

Innovation

The G20 Innovation Ministerial produced several joint statements regarding AI. Competition for AI leadership among G20 members is evident. The U.S. faces significant challenges from China in the race for AI leadership, and economic tensions have surged regarding access to advanced chips. Against this backdrop, the G20 ministers urged members to “preserve national sovereignty in the governance of emerging technologies” while emphasizing the need for human-centric and trustworthy development.

Member states published the Carolina Principles for Emerging Technologies, a set of shared aims around strengthening innovation and private-sector capabilities, accelerating commercialization, and enabling adoption of new systems. The Carolina Principles consistently emphasize reducing regulatory requirements to preserve flexibility and encourage innovation. The G20’s AI Prosperity Compact also offered member states the opportunity to pledge to put workers first in an AI-transformed world, in recognition of the impact the technology is likely to have on the labor market and domestic workforces.

Energy

Under the banner of ‘energy abundance,’ the U.S. is urging fellow G20 countries to pursue energy policies along the lines of deregulation, permitting reform, and market-driven energy production. The September 2026 ministerial in Houston produced four G20 energy-related statements on advancing access to clean cooking, domestic regulatory frameworks, water reuse, and critical minerals.

The statements primarily call on private industry to act and list voluntary actions for member states. Despite the Trump administration’s hostile posture towards environmental protection and the domestic Clean Water Act, the G20’s Water Reuse Initiative encourages member states to reduce pollution of water sources and avoid negative environmental impacts.

On critical minerals, G20 Energy Ministers emphasized “respect for national sovereignty over natural resources” while agreeing on the need to strengthen information sharing, albeit with the caveat that they will share “non-sensitive data, where appropriate, to improve visibility into challenges, bottlenecks, and market dynamics.” Members diverge from cooperation as they prioritize securing domestic supply chains, which for the U.S. and China means reducing economic dependence on each other. The language is heavily hedged: member states ‘may’ cooperate to reduce pressure on natural resource deposits, conduct collaborative research, and foster supportive investment environments. Yet nothing obliges them to do so if national interests say otherwise.

Trade and Finance

U.S. President Donald Trump’s predisposition towards protectionist trade policy and increased use of tariffs has strained many of the United States’ bilateral relationships and created uncertainties in the global trade system.

The only publicly released statement from the G20 Trade Working Group, which convened ministers in Milwaukee at the end of September, broadly condemned the weaponization of food and coercive mechanisms that disrupt agricultural and food supply chains. Notably, the statement exempts measures that are “in respect of relevant international rules and norms, and [those that] advance legitimate domestic public policy objectives.” This carve-out leaves governments with wide latitude, since protective trade restrictions such as tariffs are often framed as serving domestic goals.

As of publication, the official G20 website has not released any outcome documents from the Finance Ministers and Central Bank Governors Ministerial.

Contentious, Fracturing Order

The U.S. maintains a desired goal to “refocus the G20 into an effective organization that drives economic prosperity.” Yet, the second Trump administration has largely sought to undermine global governance architecture in the name of efficiency.

The fact that the G20’s 2026 outputs thus far are only voluntary statements, with no enforcement or accountability, reflects a fracturing world order. Diverging geopolitical interests increasingly call the forum’s vitality into question.

Scholars argue that contemporary multilateralism is increasingly “characterized by competing coalitions and shifting institutional arrangements, informal as well as formal.” As the chart below shows, several states hold seemingly contradictory memberships in prominent international organizations, informal clubs, and coalitions.

The G20 and the Board of Peace manifest as forms of contested multilateralism. The G20’s trade track provides an example of economically powerful states engaging in regime shifting, principally away from the flailing World Trade Organization (WTO). The Board of Peace embodies competitive regime creation by challenging the rules, practices, and missions of existing multilateral institutions. It also arguably erodes the G20’s prominence.

The Miami summit will test the G20’s capacity to deliver as a meaningful multilateral forum. While Washington itself has set this goal, the exclusion of South Africa one year after Pretoria hosted Africa’s first G20 summit and the Trump administration’s push to centralize American leadership diminish expectations for durable solutions.

  1. The official G20 website refers to AI as ‘SI’, a result of U.S. President Donald Trump’s expressed desire to change the name of artificial intelligence to super intelligence during his recent speech at the UN General Assembly. ↩︎

0 comments on “A Contested Forum: The 21st G20 Summit Heads to Miami”

Leave a Reply